Pergamena con la scritta Vox in excelso, MCCCXII

The bull Vox in excelso

The promulgation of the bull Vox in excelso, attributed to Pope Clement V and dated 22 March 1312 during the Council of Vienne, is the pivotal point in the events that led to the end of the activities of the Order of the Knights Templar. Historiography has traditionally regarded the act as the measure that imposed the dissolution of the institution, although its origin and its canonical validity are now the subject of a profound critical revision.

The pressure of the French crown and the “Avignon captivity”

The roots of the conflict go back to the early years of the century, when King Philip IV the Fair sought to extend the crown’s control over the property and prerogatives of the Church in French territory. After the famous episode of the “slap of Anagni”, the culmination of the tensions between Philip and Boniface VIII, the election of Clement V in 1305 and the subsequent transfer of the papal court to Avignon in 1309 radically altered the balance of power.

Avignon lay in territory belonging to the Angevins, allies of the pope, but very close to the lands controlled by the Capetian king; needing to settle his differences with Philip, Clement V found himself at a disadvantage. Although far from the struggles between Guelphs and Ghibellines in Italy (from which the Pope wished to distance himself), Avignon’s proximity to the kingdom of France exposed the Curia to constant political and military interference. The Tour Philippe-le-Bel, built by the king at Villeneuve-lès-Avignon directly opposite the papal city, was in fact a strategic stronghold from which the crown could exercise direct control and an implicit threat over the Apostolic See.

It is in this context that the French crown’s action against the Templars must be placed. For Philip the Fair, the Order was an intolerable obstacle:

  • Financially, the crown was heavily indebted to the Temple’s coffers; suppressing the Order meant wiping out the debts and seizing its wealth (a strategy the king had already applied in 1306 through the confiscation of property and the expulsion of Italian bankers and Jewish communities).
  • Politically and militarily, the Templars were an elite armed force, with commanderies and fortresses throughout the kingdom, exempt from royal authority and directly subordinate to the Pope. The king feared the presence on his soil of a potential autonomous papal army.

On 13 October 1307, applying the same pattern of force already used against Boniface VIII, Philip the Fair ordered the sudden arrest of the Templars in France, in open violation of ecclesiastical immunities and presenting the Pope with a fait accompli. Clement V sought to bring the procedure back under the jurisdiction of the Church, launching a papal inquiry with the bull Pastoralis praeminentia and convening the Council of Vienne with Regnans in excelsis.

Clement V’s dilemma

During the work of the council, held between 1311 and 1312, most of the council fathers and jurists considered it necessary to grant the Templars the right to defend themselves. A formal sentence of condemnation for heresy pronounced in court (via iustitiae), a most serious matter, required indisputable proof of the Order’s guilt.

The pontiff knew the Order’s true situation of innocence. The outcome of the investigations carried out by the plenipotentiary cardinals — as attested by the Chinon Parchment of 1308 — had clarified an essential distinction: any improper conduct or spurious rituals concerned only the individual faults of some members or of specific preceptories, while the Order as such had not fallen into heresy. The leaders of the Order had in fact been readmitted to the sacraments once their statements had been collected.

Pronouncing a condemnation for heresy would have contradicted the findings of the official investigations; on the other hand, a formal acquittal would have unleashed the reaction of Philip the Fair, who arrived in Vienne in March 1312 with his own army as a means of intimidation.

The text attributed to the bull Vox in excelso, promulgated on 22 March 1312, was the response to these opposing pressures. In the text, the Pope openly declared that he could not pronounce a definitive sentence of condemnation in accordance with the law (cum eam super hoc secundum inquisitiones et processus super his habitos non possemus ferre de iure). He therefore chose to resort to a measure of authority, suppressing the Order by way of apostolic provision (viam provisionis seu ordinationis apostolicae), while acknowledging that he had found no legal grounds to condemn it in a judicial setting.

Vox in excelso: a historical forgery

The archival records confirm that there was no condemnation of the Order as such; the decision, taken under the weight of ruthless reasons of state, leaves intact the memory of the Christian witness given by the knight brothers. The definitive proof of the Order’s innocence of the charges is found precisely in the trials held outside the direct influence of the French crown: in the provincial councils held at Tarragona and in various dioceses of the Italian peninsula, the proceedings ended with the full acquittal of the Templars of every charge of heresy.

Alongside the established historiographical record, we have always maintained, with unchanged firmness, a very specific thesis: the bull Vox in excelso is a historical forgery.

We are deeply convinced that this document is entirely devoid of legal and canonical value, given that the original parchment bearing the papal seal never existed and that the historical copies known today date only from the 19th century. From the standpoint of law, a norm for which no authenticated original act exists has no binding force; it follows that the Order of the Temple was never legally suppressed, in full accord with the stance favorable to the Templars expressed by the majority of the prelates during the Council of Vienne. We therefore hold with certainty the complete innocence of the Order of the Temple and its uninterrupted membership of the Holy Catholic Church.

Only now are recent historiographical inquiries and archival discoveries finally beginning to prove us right, highlighting the same irreparable documentary anomalies that we have long pointed out and confirming the soundness of our positions. While academic studies are taking their first steps along this path, we confidently leave to historiography the burden and the honor of shedding full light on this historical forgery, certain of the truth of our assertions and unshakeable in our defense of the spiritual memory of the knight brothers.

Historical notes: the essential chronology

  • 13 October 1307 — Philip IV orders the arrest of the Templars in France.
  • 22 November 1307 — the bull Pastoralis praeminentia: Clement V opens the papal inquiry.
  • August 1308 — the bulls Faciens misericordiam and Regnans in excelso: the inquiry into the Order and the convocation of the Council of Vienne. The Chinon Parchment (17–20 August 1308) dates from the same summer; it was rediscovered in the Vatican Apostolic Archive in 2001 by Barbara Frale.
  • 16 October 1311 — the Council of Vienne opens.
  • 22 March 1312 — the date attributed to Vox in excelso.
  • 2 May 1312 — the bull Ad providam: the Templars’ property is assigned to the Hospitallers.
  • 18 March 1314 — Jacques de Molay, the last Master General, dies at the stake in Paris.

Sources and further reading

  • Barbara Frale, Il papato e il processo ai Templari. L’inedita assoluzione di Chinon alla luce della diplomatica pontificia, Rome, Viella, 2002. The Chinon Parchment was identified in September 2001 by the author, a paleographer at the Vatican Apostolic Archive (formerly the Vatican Secret Archive), where it is kept.
  • Alain Demurger, Les Templiers. Une chevalerie chrétienne au Moyen Âge, Paris, Éditions du Seuil, 2005.
  • On the research of Sophie Kirchgasser and Daniele Mattiangeli (University of Salzburg), read our news item “The suppression of the ancient Order of the Templars was not valid”.
Contact us